Tag Archives: merit

Another third party DirectShow filter that may break your very own application

Posted by on August 5, 2009 No comments

One of the DirectShow’s most important features is Intelligent Connect, which allows Filter Graph Manager to build graphs out of independent filters trying to connect them together including options to fall back to originally non-preferred alternatives and so on.

It is however important that filters are properly registered with the Filter Mapper. For the developers to do so, there are special guidelines for registering filters. Unfortunately it is not always the case that developers carefully take them into consideration, and so we have compatibility issues. In particular a faulty filter may break an application it is not intended to be used in in first place. Some examples were already mentioned: Ahead Nero NeResize Filter, FFDShow Video Decoder Filter, PICVideo MJPEG Decompressor Filter.

As we are moving on, the brilliant collection is expanding. New entry on the list:

MainConcept Color Space Converter Filter

Friendly Name: MainConcept Color Space Converter
File Name: mccsc.ax
File Version: 1.0.103.60203 (note that other versions might be hopefully free from this problem)
Merit: 0×00600000 (MERIT_NORMAL)

Symptoms: registers itself under higher merit and takes over standard Color Space Converter Filter. As such, might be used in various applications including those, where it is not supposed to appear. Does not fully implement functionality of the filter being replaced and can crash breaking expected operation of third party application.

How To: Implement DirectShow Filter using DirectX Media Object DMO (Part 4: Merit)

Posted by on July 26, 2008 5 comments

Previously on the topic:

The implemented so far filter/DMO shown a problem related to its unexpectedly high “importance” in the system with the symptom of “auto-insertion” the filter when it is not necessary. For example, let us render an AVI file through Infinite Tee Pin Filter:

The problem is that DirectShow auto-inserts our Brightness/Contrast filter into the graph while it is obviously not expected, wanted or necessary:

The problem is high filter/DMO merit value and a popular YUY2 video format the filter is advertised to accept on input during DMO registration.

Read more »

FFDShow is getting more annoying

Posted by on June 27, 2008 No comments

Surprisingly fast I got new problems having ffdshow installed as a part of K-Lite Codec Pack. No wonder though because let us take a look at registration information:

Display Name: @device:sw:{083863F1-70DE-11D0-BD40-00A0C911CE86}\{0F40E1E5-4F79-4988-B1A9-CC98794E6B55}
CLSID: {0F40E1E5-4F79-4988-B1A9-CC98794E6B55}
Friendly Name: ffdshow Audio Decoder
Path: C:\Program Files\K-Lite Codec Pack\ffdshow\ffdshow.ax
Merit: 0x3fffffff

Nice merit, ain’t it? What is merit anyway? Let us check at MSDN:

MERIT_PREFERRED = 0×800000,
MERIT_NORMAL = 0×600000,
…
MERIT_HW_COMPRESSOR = 0×100050

The highest defined value is 0×00800000, while ffdshow is registered with 0x3FFFFFFF, that is on top of everything. No doubt the developers read Guidelines for Registering Filters and decided to get rid of the rest of installed software as unnecessary crap.

Anyway back to the problem: I had an A-law wave file (WAVE_FORMAT_ALAW) to play and make sure its data is valid and quite unexpectedly there was a silence while playing. A quick check confirmed that the sustem has CCITT A-law codec installed, however GraphEdit shown ffdshow Audio Decoder intercepting decoding. Obviously it spoiled the thing!

Finally I decided it was a right time to take an advantage of IAMGraphBuilderCallback interface to detect and reject the bastard.

Read more »